SALAFI DAKWAH AND THE DISSEMINATION OF ISLAMIC PURITANISM IN INDONESIA : A CASE STUDY OF THE RADIO OF RODJA

The article examines Islamic proselytization (dakwah) on Rodja Radio by Salafi preachers (dai). The radio program targets not only Salafis but also non-Salafi Muslims in general. It seeks to analyze the content of dakwah aired by Radio Rodja 756 AM., the leading Salafi radio station located in Cileungsi, Bogor, West Java. This article focuses mainly on current legal, social, and political issues of the Salafi dakwah. The dakwah aired by Rodja Radio intends to encourage the Muslim ummah to return to the way of life that strictly follows the tradition of the Prophet Muhammad and the first three generations of Muslims. The Salafi radio station propagates Islamic puritanism that in many ways contradicts modern values. Rodja Radio preachers demonstrate their reluctance to embrace modern ideas, such as democracy, human rights, women’s rights, and to some extent, art and education. This article reveals that the radio serves as a public sphere where the Salafis disseminate ‘Islamic Puritanism’ on Indonesian air.


RESEARCH ON THE INFLUENCE of religious broadcasting on
Indonesian society has flourished in recent years. 2 However, little research has been conducted specifically on Salafi 3 radio stations and the programs and the discourse of Islamic propagation that they broadcast.Discussion on some aspects of the Salafi radio is found in Din Wahid's PhD dissertation, which he defended at Utrecht University in 2014. 4A special work on the Salafi radio was conducted by Sunarwoto, who wrote a PhD dissertation entitled ‚'Contesting religious authority: A study on Dakwah Radio in Surakarta, Indonesia.‛ 5He later authored an article entitled ‚Salafi Dakwah Radio: A Contest for Religious Authority,‛ 6 which focused on the Salafi radio stations in Solo, such as Suara Quran, Al-Madinah, and Darussalaf.In these works, he emphasized his inquiry on religious authority.
Three other publications have discussed Rodja Radio.First, Siti Aminah wrote an MA thesis entitled ‚Strategi Informasi Konvergensi Media: Studi Kasus Radio Rodja 756 AM, Cileungsi, Bogor,‛ which focused on the change in the radio frequency from the communication technology approach. 7Second, Adeni authored an MA thesis entitled ‚Institusi Televisi Keislaman: Studi atas Rodja TV sebagai Media Islam Salafi,‛8 which focused primarily on Rodja Television.Third, the Centre for the Study of Islam and Society of State Islamic University (Universitas Islam Negeri/UIN) of Jakarta undertook research on the salafi radios around Indonesia, with one chapter focused on Rodja Radio entitled ‚Rodja: Rujukan Radio Salafi di Indonesia ,‛9 which provided a general description of Rodja Radio.Based on this information, no study has focused on the discourse of dakwah of Rodja Radio.Accordingly, it is critically important to study the content of the salafi dakwah on Rodja Radio.
My question in this essay is how do Rodja Salafi's preachers respond during the ‚question-answer‛ (tanya-jawab) sessions following Islamic religious teaching (pengajian) to such contemporary issues as LGBT, Islamic penal law, education and technology, and women's rights?Their answers illustrate how they interpret Muslim life in the modern era and what solutions they offer to a wide variety of the factors behind those issues.The study thus aims to describe the content of the salafi dakwah that is broadcasted by Rodja Radio.I argue that the salafi radio propagates an Islamic puritanical way of life that challenges the values and principles of modern society.The idea of a 'rejection to the modern ideas and values' is, of course, not peculiar to Muslims since this is found in other religious traditions.I show that the preachers of Rodja Radio preachers are reluctant to embrace modern ideas.They reject and criticize democracy, human rights, women's rights, art and education.This article reveals that the radio serves as a medium through which the salafi spread 'Islamic Puritanism' and ‚Islam as a Transnational Public Space,‛ to borrow a phrase coined by John Bowen,10 in Indonesia and beyond.
Salafism, Islamic Puritanism, and the Public Sphere I was unaware of the religious affiliation of Rodja Radio until attentively listening to its programs in 2015-2016, which clearly revealed their Islamic salafi ideology.Salafism 11 is the Islamic ideology held by a Muslim community or group that attempt to revive the Sunnah/Tradition of the Prophet Muhammad and revitalize the way of life of the first three Muslim generations in the modern era. 12According to Henri Lauziere, there are two types of Salafism: first is Modernist Salafism.This refers to ‚a multifaceted movement of Islamic modernism that took shape in the late nineteenth century and lasted until the mid-twentieth century‛ with its 'founding fathers' Jamaluddin al-Afghani, Muhammad Abduh, and Muhammad Rashid Riḍa.The modernist Salafism aims ‚to reconcile Islam to social, political, and intellectual ideals to Modernism and to rearticulate Islam to the contemporary realities and to the rational minds.‛ 13The second is Purist Salafism, which refers to ‚the most authentic and purist religious orientation within Sunni-Islam‛ comprising those who claim ‚to follow the only true Islam that can lead to the salvation.‛ 14Purist Salafism rejects all form of innovation (bid'a), deviation (inḥirāf), accretion (ziyada), speculative theology ('ilm kalam), and philosophy.Lauziere has rightly pointed out that Purist Salafism is ‚not compromised with potential impurities from all aspects in the religion, misguided beliefs and actions including its epistemology, and denies the validity of any intuitive or esoteric knowledge.They put the supremacy and primacy of scriptural (naql) over rational proofs ('aql).‛ 15Lauziere identified this as Purist Salafism and even used the term ‚purist‛ ‚to convey the persistent preoccupation of today's Salafi with religious purity‛. 16alafism is here conceived of as Islamic puritanism. 17It should be noted that, when the term ‚puritanism‛ is used here, it does not replicate or follow literally the history of the Christian puritans in Europe.According to The New Oxford Dictionary of English, the terms ‚puritan‛ and ‚puritanism‛ were firstly used to refer to ‚The beliefs or principles of a group of English Protestants of the late 16th and 17th centuries who regarded the Reformation of the Church under Elizabeth I as incomplete and sought to simplify and regulate forms of worship.‛ 18In brief, puritanism can be 13 He nri Lauzie re , The Making of Salafism: Islamic Reform in the Twentieth Century (Ne w York: Columbia Unive rsity Pre ss, 2016), 5.
18 Se e the e ntrie s on ‚puritan‛ and ‚puritanism‛ in J A Simpson and E S C We ine r, New Oxford Dictionary of English (Oxford: Oxford Unive rsity Pre ss, 1998), and online ve rsion ‚Puritan,‛ Oxford Dictionaries, acce sse d June 19, 2018, understood as purification movements and an appeal and a call to return to the pure teaching of religion.The dakwah broadcast by Rodja Radio represents exactly what Lauziere has explained about salafism.In other words, Salafism is far more suited to being identified with Islamic puritanism than the other categories.
This labeling is corroborated by Khaled Abou El Fadl, who considers Salafi-Wahabi as Muslim Puritans or the Puritans of Islam. 19According to him, there exist two categories of Muslim: Muslim moderates and Muslim puritans, both of whom believe that their beliefs are based on the Qur'an and the authentic tradition of the Prophet Muhammad. 20Muslim moderates describe aptly the religious convictions of the majority of Muslims.In fact, the Qur'an enjoins Muslims to be moderate as stated in Sura al-Baqara 143 ‚And thus we have made you a just community‛.The Prophet Muhammad was always described as a moderate man who tended to avoid falling into extremes.Therefore, according to Abou El Fadl, ‚the word moderate has roots in the Islamic tradition and it conveys the normative disposition<that aptly describes the religious convictions of the majority of Muslims.‛ 21Muslims puritans are group of Muslims ‚with the distinguishing characteristic which is the absolutist and uncompromising nature of its beliefs.‛ 22In this sense, I agree even more with Abou El Fadl, who labels this group as ‚puritans‛ rather than fundamentalists, militants, extremists, radicals, fanatics, jihadists, or even simply Islamists. 23In fact, their orientation ‚tends to be purist, in the sense that it is intolerant of competing points of view and considers pluralist realities to be a form of contamination of the unadulterated truth.‛ 24Based on this explanation, the term ‚Islamic puritanism‛, used in this article, refers to a literal interpretation of the principal source of Islam (literalism) and appeal to the way of life of the Prophet and restoration of the spirit of the first three generations to what they were.It calls all Muslims to behave and live according to the standard of ‚glory and golden age of Islam‛ during the first three centuries of Early Islam.Their ideology is to purify what they consider non-compliance with religious doctrine and teaching as mentioned in the Qur'an and Sunna.They oppose what they perceive to be innovation in religious matters (bid'a) and strictly and literally follow the Prophetic tradition.Therefore, they call themselves Ahl al-Athar or Ahl al-Sunnah (followers of tradition and companion). 25t is interesting to see how effectively a public sphere is used by religious radio to propagate and disseminate a certain ideology.‚The power of religion in the public sphere‛ 26 is used by a group of salafi using radio to disseminate their teachings and messages.The ‚public sphere‛ here refers to what the German Philosopher and Sociologist Jurgen Habermas defined as: public being ‚<when they are open to all in contrast to closed or exclusive affairs‛ and the public sphere is ‚a society engaged in critical public debate.‛ 27The public sphere is, therefore, a social space that is open to all members of society, regardless of their color, race, ethnicity, and religion, because it belongs to the public.All public arenas contribute toward creating an open and social culture by 23  sharing common knowledge with others and radio is one of the public arenas.We will demonstrate that a specific group of Salafi in Indonesia has been using the public sphere for several years to diffuse their ideology across Indonesian Muslim society and beyond.The thesis in this article is that Rodja Radio has made significant efforts to ‚salafize‛ Indonesian Islam through the medium of radio.
This article is based on research that I conducted over an eight-month period.I listened to Rodja Radio broadcasts almost daily from January to June of 2016.However, I made notes on anything I merely considered interesting because of the way in which the preachers responded to the current legal, social and political issues, as requested by Rodja Radio's listeners.I interviewed Rodja Radio's preachers, managers, and its listeners.Although I amassed a lot of other information broadcasted, my focus was on the content of the dakwah.Rodja Radio is concerned with a variety of dakwah topics on Hadith and Sunnah (the Prophets' sayings/narrations and Prophetic tradition), Tafsīr (Quran interpretation), Sīrah (Islamic history), Fiqh (Islamic law), Aqīdah and Tawḥīd (theology).My intention here is not to present a fully detailed study of how Rodja Radio operates in every aspect, but to limit the discussion to the content of its dakwah.

Salafi Dakwah on Rodja Radio
To protect Indonesian society from the moral degradation caused by the infidel (kafir) Western culture, Salafis believe in the need to launch dakwah radio stations.Even though Westerners invented and developed this means of mass broadcasting, Salafis eventually allowed its use in order to preach on matters of religion, Islamic public order, and morality among their Muslim fellows.In 2004, a group of young Salafis 28 from Kampung Tengah, Cileungsi, Bogor, West Java, met and decided to propagate and disseminate pure dakwah in order to 'protect' the belief (aqīdah/tawḥīd) of the Muslim community from bid'ah (unlawful innovations in religious matters).In early 2005, they established the Rodja Radio station, based simply on the Islamic principle of 'opposing evil and enjoining good' and that 'every innovation is a misguidance and every misguidance leads to hellfire.' 29 Managed by a small but creative group, in its first five years, Rodja Radio grew slowly but surely and expanded rapidly across Indonesia.Over the following five years, an innovative array of products was added. 30More than sixty-five radio stations in Indonesia rely on Rodja Radio's dakwah programs. 31Furthermore, 'influential' Salafi radio stations in Java rely on Rodja Radio and import their dakwah. 32No radio rating has been carried out regarding this Salafi radio station.However, according to www.radioguide.com,which rates (for every category) the top forty radio stations in Indonesia, Rodja Radio is one of the most listened radio stations (number 7). 33In comparison, www.korando.comlisted Rodja Radio in the 77 th amongst the top one hundred radio stations in Indonesia. 34These ratings show that Rodja Radio has a place in Indonesia within the religious radio category.
There exist no reliable data on how many Indonesian Muslims listen to Rodja Radio.It has been claimed that more 100,000 people are 'faithful' listeners to Rodja Radio dakwah programs. 35If this figure is correct, then there is no doubt that Rodja Radio is the leading Salafi radio station in Indonesia although the figure is still lower than those of other public radios.ELSHINTA, a leading news radio station, has more than 1.3 million listeners and this number has been growing since ELSHINTA has seven branches 29 Rodja is an abbre viation from RadiO Dakwah ahlus sunnah wal Jamaah (Propagation Radio of the Adhe re nts to the Sunnah and the Followe rs). 30Rodja ope rates satellite tele vision, a radio streaming satellite radio station, online radio and flexi radio, as we ll as an Islamic boarding school for me morizing the Quran, an Islamic kinde rgarte n and an Islamic inte grate d primary school.
31 Inte rvie w with Dian Sudiana Fawwaz on We dne sday,29 June 2016. 32 and 31 radio stations that rely on its broadcasting in Indonesia.GEN FM, a music radio station, has more than 4.1 million listeners in Jakarta, and in the surrounding areas (Depok, Bogor, Tangerang, and Bekasi), there are 3.4 million listeners.Accordingly, we can believe the management team of Rodja Radio's claim that its listeners number in the hundred thousand range.Moreover, the number of Rodja Radio listeners could be more than a hundred thousand because it has five branches of the Rodja Radios, in Bandung, Berau, Lampung, Tanjung Pinang, and Pontianak.In addition, 65 radio stations around Indonesia rely on its Islamic broadcasting.This number would rise if we consider Rodja Radio's streaming and satellite options.One may estimate that Rodja's Radio broadcasts might reach more than one million listeners.
Based on this information, the number of people who listen to Rodja Radio has been increasing in Indonesia although no exact data of its listener is available.Another fact is that Rodja Radio has organized several huge gatherings in the Istiqlal mosque and other large mosques, which a hundred thousand people attended.They came along to these Islamic gatherings because they listen to Rodja Radio.From this simple fact alone, it is important to discover which issues the radio station addresses in its preaching and what the impact of Rodja Radio will be on the future of Indonesia.

Issues related to the Salafi Dakwah on Rodja Radio
I and my researcher assistant randomly interviewed more than 80 people others in Jakarta and its surroundings about the content of dakwah broadcast on Rodja Radio and their reaction to it. 36The findings revealed that they are very concerned about Rodja Radio because it promotes basic Islamic teachings.I chose four issues of the dakwah contain, as they deal with the problem of the relations between Islam and the ideas of modernism, which are the central criticism of Salafism.Therefore, my discussion focuses on four major issues that arose during the live broadcast interactive programs (question and answer sessions) between the preachers and listeners. 37t should be noted that nearly all of Indonesian preachers on Rodja Radio are graduates of the Islamic University of Medina in Saudi Arabia or the Islamic University of Muhammad Ibn Saud in Jakarta (LIPIA), while a few others studied at a small number of universities in Yemen and Pakistan. 38Jajang Jahroni 39 and Amanda Kovacs 40 showed that Saudi Arabia used education, through scholarship to study at LIPIA, financed school and mosque construction, and built Islamic schools, as a political strategy for maintaining its influence over Indonesia.In fact, LIPIA represents a microcosm of Saudi ideology, in which Salafi-Wahhabi norms and tradition prevail.Accordingly, it directly influences its students, who later become religious teachers and dai, as their agency is to spread Salafi-Wahhabi teachings within Indonesian society, who mostly do not follow the Salafi-Wahabism.As a result, LIPIA, as the Salafi model education, challenge moderate Indonesian Islam and instigate the growth of puritanical understanding of Islam, which lead into conservatism and even radicalism. 41Below are examples of the Salafis' Islamic discourse on the Rodja Radio.
The ustadh answered the question as follows: ‚Be ing a me mbe r of the LGBT community is without doubt a huge sin.Allah, the most glorifie d and the most high, narrated the story of the pe ople of the prophe t Luth and how He punishe d the m se verely.The ir torme nt is a le sson for the pe ople living afte r the m.Allah, the most glorifie d and the most high, abhorre d of this be havior and, e ve n more , the Prophe t Muhammad, pe ace be upon him, curse d the ir be havior.The prophe t said 'may Allah, the most glorifie d and the most high, curse me n who re se mble wome n and wome n who re semble men'.Most ulamas (Islamic scholars) have writte n in the ir books, that be ing LGBT in Islam is punishe d by the de ath pe nalty.In fact, it is an alarming dise ase that could be transmitte d to othe r pe ople and de struct their be havior.First, this dise ase will de stroy human life and harm social life .Imagine that me n love me n and wome n love wome n.The re will no births or de scendants at all.Human life will be come e xtinct in the world.Se cond, be ing an LGBT is against the primordial human nature (fiṭrah) that Allah, the most glorifie d and the mos t high, be stowe d on human be ings from the outse t: me n love wome n and vice -ve rsa.Allah, the most glorifie d and the most high, did not cre ate human be ings in LGBT conditions.In nature , no humans are born as LGBT.Accordingly, LGTB should be fought against and e liminated.We can fight LGBT through viole nt and pe aceful actions.Parents have to prote ct the ir childre n from LGBT.The y must take care of the ir childre n's e ducation and the ir social inte raction.Eve rybody must stand toge the r against LGBT and we do not want our ne w ge ne rations to be come e xtinct be cause of this LGBT dise ase .Those who support LGBT dislike re ligion.The y dislike Allah, the most glorifie d and the most high, and the Prophe t, pe ace be upon him.The y are not be lie ve rs (mu'min) and do not fe ar Allah's punishme nt (muttaqin).The y me re ly live he re in this world (dunya) and only follow the ir own de sire s (shahwat).We ask the gove rnme nt NOT to allow this contagious LGBT dise ase have any rights in this country.Othe rwise , it will invite the ange r of Allah, the most glorifie d and the most high.‛ 43stadh Abu Yahya Badrussalam, LC.The ustadh's answer was meant to remind the entire Indonesian Muslim society to be mindful of LGBT.Moreover, his last sentences are clearly intimidating to any Muslims who support and tolerate LGBT, especially Muslim Human Rights activists and liberal Muslims as he qualifies them as non-believers.
The next week, I listened to a question-answer session on the same issue, but this time is centered on punishment: ‚What is the punishment for those who love a person of the same sex?‛ 44 The ustadh answered: ‚The punishme nt for same sex love rs is to be thrown from a high place and to rain stone s on the m as mentioned in the Quran, Hud/11:82 45 .Inde e d, there are various opinions re garding the way pe rpe trators should be punishe d.Some ulama (Islamic scholars) said the y should be kille d while othe r said the y should be stone d (rajam).The Prophe t said 'If you find a pe rson who sodomize d his love r, the n kill the m both.'The gove rnment must imple me nt this punishme nt and nobody has the right to do in the place of gove rnme nt.In the same vein, a pe rson who make s love with a dog should be kille d, both the pe rpe trator and the dog, according to the Prophe t.What about le sbians?Le sbian are conde mne d to ta'zīr, the punishme nt de cide d upon by the gove rnme nt.‛ Ustadh Mahfudz Umri, LC.
Muslim preachers normally based their answeres on the Quranic, hadis, and fiqh norms rather than on national regulations or the international legal system.The salafi preachers' response to LGBT issues shows actually that they are strongly committed to implementing their conservative interpretation of Islam .They do so to strengthen traditional and conservative religious understanding.They aim to educate Muslim families and individuals to strongly refrain from becoming LGBT persons or even LGBT supporters.

Issues on Islamic Penal Law
Another controversial issue that I found interesting in another question-answer session is concerned with Islamic penal law.On Saturday 16 January 2016, a listener inquired about the 44 Rodja Radio broadcast on Tue sday, 12 April, at about 19.25.punishment for theft in Islam as he found that in Indonesian society, people would punish a thief in their own way, sometimes even leading to the thief's death.Ustadh Ahmad Ridwan, LC. replied that stealing should be punished by cutting off the hand.
In the following months, many listeners asked questions about Islamic penal law such as the example below.
He re in Indone sia, the ft is not punishe d by hand cutting and ille gal se xual re lationships (zina) are not sentenced to de ath by stoning (rajam).What is the opinion on those who do not follow the laws of the Quran?Ple ase give us the e xplanation. 46e ustadh answered: ‚Your que stion is ve ry good.Those who re je ct the principle s of Islam and the te achings of the Qur'an and the hadis only follow the ir de sire s and lusts (shahwat).He re in Indone sia, the gove rnme nt should take re sponsibility against those who de viate , because of the ir re je ction to abide to the laws of Allah.Many pe ople de clare that the y are Muslims, but the y do not put the laws of Allah in practice .This is one form of be ing astray (sesat) and for the m, what matte rs more is the State (the y are conce rne d only with the State ).The prophe t, peace be upon him, said 'you have to strictly hold on to the two pillars, the n you are save d, the y are the Quran and my Sunna .Accordingly, those who do not follow my Sunna are misguide d.‛ Ustadh Ahmad Zainuddin, LC.
Apart from being astray or misguided, Radio Rodja also categorized those who reject the laws of Allah as hypocrites (munāfiq) such as in the program it aired on Friday, 15 January 2016, from around 17.20 to 17.40.
Are the re any justifiable reasons that allow us to kill a pe rson and what are the proce dure s? 47 Bapak Yusuf from Be kasi ‚The re are among us who have kille d anothe r pe rson without any justifiable re ason and the Prophe t, peace be upon him, said that one of the re asons why pe ople kill othe rs is that the y did not use the ir common sense.Indee d, the re are re asons that justify killing a pe rson.For e xample , a gove rnme nt or a judge se ntences a pe rson to de ath for re asons justifie d by our re ligion: he /she kille d anothe r pe rson or caused serious damage on e arth, or married wome n who had committe d adulte ry.According to the Prophe t, pe ace be upon him, 46 Rodja Radio broadcast on Saturday, 11 March 2016, from around 18.30 to 20.00. 47Rodja Radio broadcast on Tue sday, 15 March 2016, from around 05.30 to 07.00.
'Is not lawful to impose the de ath pe nalty e xce pt in thre e case s: some one who kille d anothe r pe rson inte ntionally, and those who commit adulte ry or apostasy.'The se are the reasons for which the gove rnme nt can impose the de ath pe nalty.‛Ustadh Arman Amri, LC.
Based on the answers given by Rodja preachers, it seems that in criminal cases they want to implement Quranic penal law and follow the Tradition of the Prophet literally.Their standing on the enactment of Islamic penal law shows that they are strongly committed to implementing their conservative interpretation of Islamic law.The salafi preachers have seemingly acquired an aura of authority and legitimacy.Their rigid position and their mere citing and literally following of the Quranic law to solve social problems tells us that they are inflexible in their search for solutions suited to modern Indonesian Muslim society.Instead of calling to obey the national legal system or a more justifiable Islamic law, they preach to implement Islamic penal law as solution.

Issues on Education and Technology
Part of Salafi dakwah on Rodja Radio reveals its rejection of music or of some subjects, such as philosophy or tasawuf (Islamic spirituality and mysticism) that might be taught to students, as the following question-answer session demonstrates: What is the rule on music in Islam? 48The preacher answered: ‚Music in Islam is ḥarām (unlawful) be cause many ne gative aspe cts are found in music, such as e njoyme nt and me re killing time be cause of which much time is waste d.It would be be tte r to re ad the Holy Quran and praise Allah, the most glorifie d and the most high, rathe r than to pla y the guitar.‛Ustadh Jazuli, LC.
The same question was raised by a listener three days later: What is the Islamic rule on music or singing?Is it ḥarām to te ach music or singing to stude nts? 49 Te acher from Palangkaraya The ustadh answered: ‚Eve rything that is forbidde n in sharia is unlawful to te ach to pupils and childre n.Ḥarām (unlawful) re mains ḥarām and the re sult of something that is ḥarām is ḥarām.The re fore, it is totally wrong to offe r stude nts something that is ḥarām like offe ring the m music or singing le ssons.Te aching music or singing is like te aching how to se ll narcotics and drugs.This is ḥarām and do you want your childre n to have the skill to se ll narcotics?So, you have to te ach something that is good for the ir future and not te ach the m some thing that is ḥarām.‛Ustadh Kholid Syamsuddin Rodja Radio categorizes studying philosophy also as being ḥarām: What is the Islamic rule on studying philosophy?What if some one take s a class on philosophy just to ge t a passing grade ?Ple ase e xplain to us. 50bdullah from Cikarang, Be kasi.
The preacher answered: ‚All Islamic scholars ('ulama) agre e that studying philosophy is ḥarām (unlawful and ille gal).According to Imam S hāfi'ī, the punishme nt for spe culative the ologian and philosophe rs is to ge t be ate n by a branch of the date palm.It is be tte r to le arn the ology (me : according to Ḥanbalī theology) than philosophy.In fact, philosophy can damage the mind and de struct the faith, be cause in philosophy to ge t to know Allah, the Cre ator, one only ne e ds to use the mind, while the human mind is ve ry limite d.So, that is why all Muslim scholars agre e that studying and le arning about philosophy is ḥarām.Just le arn and study the ology, not philosophy.The diffe re nce be twe e n the ology and philosophy is ve ry small; the ology came afte r philosophy.‛Ustadh Abu Yahya Badrussalam, LC.
Another interdiction in education is to study and practice tasawuf (Sufism or mysticism): What is the rule in Islam to learn about and practice tasawuf? 51The preacher answered: ‚Studying and practicing tasawuf (mysticism/Sufism) is ḥarām (unlawful and ille gal).Sufism could le ad you to go astray and be come misguide d (sesat).Sufism will le ad to unbe lie f and infide lity (kekufuran).In Sufism, you will be taught not to pe rform the praye rs (ṣalat) be cause the se praye rs are not obligatory in Sufism.In Sufism, you will de ny and ne gate the ritual obligations in Islam.‛Ustadh Abdullah Taslim, LC. 50Rodja Radio broadcast on We dne sday, 13 April 2016. 51Rodja Radio broadcast on Thursday, 28 January 2016, from around 06.45 to 07.15.
Salafi dakwah on Rodja Radio is against technology since it might lead to negative things.However, Rodja Radio uses technology for its dakwah purposes, which reveals its ambivalence towards modern life.Some questions concern the Internet and television: What is the Islamic rule on the Internet? 52The preacher answered: ‚Inte rnet is ḥarām (unlawful and ille gal) as it contains ne gative things such as pornography.When used to le arn something good and positive , one may use the Inte rne t, but ple ase stay away from the Inte rne t.‛ Ustadh Abdullah Zae n, MA.
What is the rule in Islam on television? 53The ustadh answered: ‚Watching te le vision is allowe d but de pe nds on the inte ntion and the purpose of watching it.You can watch te le vision that te ache s the Sunnah.Othe rwise , it is ḥarām.Watching te levision is ḥarām and forbidde n be cause it shows things that are ḥarām.According to Ibn Baz, it is unlawful to watch te le vision be cause you will watch obscene scenes.You watch wome n on the te le vision and thus it is ḥarām.‛

Ustadh Abdul Hakim Abdat
Education and technology are important in daily life.The preacher's answers on Rodja Radio may be seen as unsuitable to the modern world.Rodja Radio makes no attempt to adapt Islamic doctrines and teachings to the views of the world in the 21 st century.The Salafi rejects technology such as Internet, radio, and television.However, they use them which are also technology.Can it be explained as inconsistency or is there a different degree by the Salafi in accepting and accommodating technology?I do not know.Indeed, further research needs to be done to answer such questions.In short, this shows merely the paradox of Rodja: they criticized the modern technology, but they use for their own dakwah.

On Women's Issues
Other interesting topics to look at more closely on the dakwah presented by Rodja Radio are those pertaining to women's issues such as the following: What is the rule in Islam on women going to a mall, the market, or a commercial center? 54The preacher answered: ‚Wome n may go to the marke t or a mall, but not in orde r to e ngage in tabarruj (to ove rdre ss or to flaunt).If a woman goe s to a marke t or a comme rcial ce nte r, she should not we ar a dre ss and must not we ar pe rfume on he r clothes or on he r body.In fact, the marke t is a place of the de vil (setan).Women should not use pe rfume, because it will attract pe ople .She would be like a prostitute , na'udhu billah, we ask Allah's prote ction.‛Ustadh Abu Yahya Badrussalam, LC.
In the following days, the topic on women remained the same.The issues centered around fitna (temptation and disorder) that might create temptation and disorder in society according to the preaching of Ustadh Abu Yahya Badrussalam. 55nother question was on women workers: I want to ask a que stion.What is the rule in Islam on wome n who work as a civil se rvant outside the ir home with the inte ntion to work for Allah and to support the ir familie s?I ask your e xplanation. 56biatul Adawiyyah from Jakarta The preacher answered: ‚The re are some justifiable re asons that allow wome n to have a care e r (to work).First, the y should have the pe rmission of the ir husbands.Se cond, the y must first e xe rcise and pe rform the ir role s and obligations as mothe rs and house wive s.Third, the re should not be any ikhtilath, mixing be twe e n me n and wome n in the workplace .Howe ve r, it is be st for wome n to sta y at home in orde r to e xe cute he r obligations as mothers and housewive s, if the ir husbands fulfill the ne e ds of the ir familie s.This is to safe the m from fitna (te mptation and disorde r ).Eve n more , wome n will re ce ive much more re ward (pahala) if the y do the ir tasks and obligations at home .‛Ustadh Mahfudz Umri, LC.
Another question on women workers was: The preacher answered: ‚Base d on the ve rse ‚Wa qarna fī buyūtikum…‛ that oblige s wome n to stay at home , the y should do so.It is be tte r whe n wome n stay at home .It will bring about the re ward and the ble ssing of Allah, the most glorifie d and the most high.Howe ve r, te aching is allowe d in Islam, if the te aching is about sharia issue s.‛ Ustadh Abu Ya'la Kurnae di, LC.
One preacher gave a shocking answer: The preacher answered: ‚Why you do not marry he r to a good Muslim?The proble m for wome n worke rs is that the y be come more inde pende nt be cause of the mone y the y e arn from the ir work and accordingly the y do not want to take care of the ir childre n, the y ne gle ct the ir dutie s to raise the ir childre n.The re fore , it is be tte r for wome n, e ven more so for young girls, to stay at home.This is what Allah said in the Quran (Sura al-Aḥzāb/33:33): ‚And abide in your house s and do not display yourse lve s as *was+ the display of the forme r time s of ignorance ‛.Howe ve r, if she wants to work, she has to choose a j ob that complie s with the Sunna .‛

Ustadh Abdul Hakim Abdat
The preacher ordered a father to marry off his daughter instead of allowing her to work or to study.He was adamant to limit women to do their domestic work without thinking of their future.
Rodja's preacher even wants to restrict women's role in dakwah: I have two que stions: what is the Islamic rule on wome n pre ache rs in propagating and disse minating Islam?And why do wome n inhe rit a smalle r share of the inhe ritance than me n? 60 Abu Mizan from East Jakarta The preacher answered: ‚Talking about issue on dakwah by wome n, the re is in fact the basic principle of ‚Al-nisā'u shaqā'iq al-rijāl‛, ‫النساء‬ ‫شقائق‬ ‫الرجال‬ me aning 'wome n are the siste rs of me n.' Whe n Allah aske d pe ople to e ngage in dakwah, He addre sse d His me ssage (khiṭāb) to me n.Inde e d, Allah allows wome n pre ache rs (wome n who e ngage in dakwah) in Islam but not to the e xte nt of me n.Wome n may e ngage in dakwah, but it should be in Islamic corridor.De aling with your se cond que stion on the diffe rent shares of an inhe ritance be twe e n me n and wome n in Islam, in fact you have no right and are not allowe d to ask such que stion!Allah has alre ady de cide d all laws in the Quran and He knows the be st for His se rvants, be cause He is The All-Knowing (al-' Alīm) and The Most-Judicious (al-Ḥakīm).Obviously, Allah Himse lf de cide d in the Quran, sura al-Nisā', that the share of me n is twice that of wome n 61 .It may se e m that Allah is unjust and unfair, but He de cide d as such be cause the re is wisdom be hind the diffe re nce of the ir share s.Wome n in Islam are not oblige d to work be cause that is the obligation of me n.‛ Ustadh Abu Ya'la Kurnae di, LC.
Another question I found interesting was about women's participation in politics and social-activism.
What is the rule in Islam if wome n participate in political life only for Allah, the most glorifie d and the most high? 62a from Jakarta The preacher answered: ‚Thank you for your que stion.In this e ra, a woman is allowe d to participate in a political move me nt and in a political party, but she should conside r many things.In fact, wome n have obligations and it has to be the ir priority to e xe cute the se obligations, such as taking care of the ir husbands and childre n.It is me ntione d that wome n are the le ade rs in managing the ir husbands' houses and childre n.As the matter of fact, the place of wome n is at home and that should be the ir priority be fore doing activitie s outside .‛Ustadh Ahmad Zainuddin, LC.
What is the rule for wome n activists (wome n who are active ) in NGOs, such as NGOs or Move me nts that colle ct funding and donations from the pe ople ?Is it allowe d in Islam? 63 64mothe r from Jakarta ‚It is be tte r if wome n sta y at home.The y have to e xecute their obligations as house wive s.The y must obe y the ir husbands.So, wome n should e xe cute the ir tasks at home .‛

Ustadh Abu Ihsan Al-Atsary
The salafi preachers obviously restrict women's rights and limit their roles to domestic realms.They restrict women's participation in social and political life and even disallow them to work as teachers.Salafi preachers act as a task force to re-Islamize Indonesian women since they accuse them of being westernized which they consider immoral.

Rodja and Islamic Puritanism
The content of the Rodja Radio dakwah echoes the literal understanding of Islam and challenges the majority moderate 62 Rodja Radio broadcast on We dne sday, 16 March 2016 (live ) from around 10.00 to 11.00 and on We dne sday, 30 March 2016 (re -broadcaste d) around 14.50.
Islamic perception of Indonesian Muslims.The four issues I presented above pose serious problems to Indonesian Muslim society.On the one hand, they have to struggle to enter modern life but, on the other, salafi dakwah doctrine prevents this.Salafi dakwah is extremely rigid and differs significantly from that of the majority of preachers, who are more flexible, and remain very popular among the ordinary people.However, the penetration of Indonesian society by social media has caused this salafi dakwah to gain popularity and grow rapidly among Indonesian society.Rodja Radio repeatedly states that Muslims who do not follow the pure, rigid Prophetic tradition (Ḥadīth and Sunna ) and engage in religious innovation are idolatrous.This is even truer when we consider the answers of the salafi preachers, which, no doubt, create puritan, ultra-conservative, fundamentalist or even radical views that may promote intolerance and exclusivism among the people.The salafi preachers are strongly committed to educating and enlightening the general Muslim community who, according to them, still remains far removed from the practice of true Islam.Salafi-Wahhabi preachers urge Muslim communities to indulge in the same religious ideology of salafism.They ignore human beings' plural nature despite the clarity of the Quranic statements, such as those found in QS. 11: 118 ‚And if your Lord had willed, He could have made mankind one community, but they will not cease to differ;‛ and in QS. 10:99 ‚And had your Lord willed, those on earth would have believed -all of them entirely.Then, O Muhammad, would you compel the people in order that they become believers?‛God created human beings to be different and wants them to know each other and build a better world, as mentioned in QS. 49:13 ‚O mankind, indeed We have created you as male and female and made you peoples and tribes that you may know one another.Indeed, the most noble of you in the sight of Allah is the most righteous of you.Indeed, Allah is Knowing and Acquainted.‛ 6565 Inte rvie w with many Muslim liste ne rs in Jakarta and its surroundings be twe e n Fe bruary and May 2016.

Implications of Rodja Radio for Indonesian Islam
Rodja Radio is undoubtedly one of the most influential stations that has shaped Islamic discourse in Indonesia.It is dedicated to spreading salafi doctrines and Wahabism.Supported by a group of committed, highly innovative individuals, Rodja Radio has expanded its dakwah across the whole of Indonesia through partnerships with local radio stations.The dakwah of Rodja Radio potentially cause people to develop radical and sectarian tendencies due to its strict and literal understanding of the Islamic doctrines.The number of people who subscribe to Salafi dakwah on Rodja Radio may grow, which could pose a threat to the diversity and plurality of Indonesian society.The Salafi communities have strong networks that consist of committed individuals who wish to share and disseminate puritanism thinking.
The growing number of followers of, and listeners to, the Salafi Rodja Radio has become increasingly visible because of their special forms of Islamic expression: sporting a beard, a black forehead, trousers above the ankle, and wearing a complete veil.Based on the four aforementioned issues on the dakwah materials promoted by the Salafi preachers on Rodja Radio, Salafism has given another 'color' to Indonesian Islam.
Even though no statistical data exist that prove a direct relationship between the Salafi discourse on Rodja Radio and Islamic Muslim practice, such as radicalism, the implication cannot be ignored.Moderate Indonesian Muslims are represented by two largest Islamic mass organizations Nahdlatul Ulama and Muhammadiyah. 66One example that must be mentioned here is what NU has been doing to counter this salafization of Indonesian Muslims.In other words, NU has devoted efforts to counter Salafi preaching on Rodja Radio.They implement creative programs in mosques in order to make mosque management more professional and provide with more solid counter-narrative arguments against Salafi-Wahhabi preachers.Some training programs and education for Imams (mosque managers/leaders) and religious teachers (ustaz)   Radio Silaturahim, etc.) and televisions (such as TV 9 Nusantara, NU Channel, TV NU, etc.) promote moderate and tolerant Islam as a counter discourse against the Rodja Radio broadcast on Salafism.
The main contents of the syllabus of the training are based on the philosophy of Islam Nusantara that is a result of the blending and merging of Islam within Indonesian culture.In fact, the essence of Islam Nusantara is to adopt Islam as its principal source of the Truth (al-Qur'an, Ḥadīth, Ijmā', and Qiyās) but simultaneously to do so with respect for local cultures and values that do not conflict with Islamic teachings and doctrines. 68Islam Nusantara is an interpretation of Islam that takes into account the local Indonesian customs in forming its fiqh (Islamic law) or social, political and religious practices.In other words, Islam has interacted with the culture and values of Indonesia.Islam Nusantara has paved the way for turning Indonesia into a tolerant, ideas, such as democracy, human rights, women's rights, and, to some extent, art and education, and condemn Indonesian religious practices.
The question is that why this has happened.Van Bruinessen explained two factors that have made Indonesian Islam more conservative.First, democracy, which Indonesian gained in 1998 after the fall of Suharto, opened the gate to freedom of expression and created free public space in which to express faith, religious behavior and religious thought. 72Prior to this democratization process, pre-1998, the 'fundamentalist, radical, puritanical, and extremist' Islamic discourse (like Salafi-Wahhabi) was repressed and imprisoned by the Suharto authoritarian regime.The Suharto regime only gave voice to moderate Muslims (MUI, NU, and Muhamadiyyah).After the reformasi era, the public space became open to everyone, including the most puritanical people, like the Salafi-Wahhabi preachers on Rodja Radio, and the increasing influence of the Middle-East, mainly the Arabian peninsula, in the form of returning graduates from Saudi universities Saudi-owned and Saudi or Kuwaiti-funded educational institutions in Indonesia, sponsored translations of numerous simple ‚fundamentalist‛ texts, and ideological as well as financial support for transnational Islamic movements. 73I have explained above that the majority of Salafi-Wahhabi preachers on Rodja Radio graduated from Saudi universities (in Riyadh and Medina) or in LIPIA Jakarta.They became agencies (religious teachers and dai) for spreading the teachings and messages of the Salafi-Wahhabi-Saudi version of Islam.
As was correctly pointed out by Khaled Abou El Fadl, these Muslim puritans always ‚accuse moderates of having changed and reformed Islam to the point of diluting and corrupting it.And moderates accuse the puritans of miscomprehending and misapplying Islam to the pint of undermining and even defiling the religion.‛ 74However, on certain issues, they are inconsistent in their preaching.They condemn the use of technology, such as 72 Ibid., 5. 73 Ibid. 74Abou El Fadl, The Great Theft , 5. radio, television, and the internet, but use them for their own dakwah purposes.It is also important to note that even among the Salafi Rodja Radio's preachers; they do not have a common answer.For instance, regarding their opinion of women's work, one preacher's view is more flexible, while another's is very strict.They respond to the question differently.In general, dakwah on Salafi Rodja Radio on women fosters teaching and doctrines that are not 'friendly' to women.Salafi preachers have been spreading authoritarian, ultra-conservative, purist and fundamentalist ideas on Islamic doctrine.

Conclusion
In the rapidly-growing urbanized Indonesian society, Rodja Radio has played an important role in building the Salafi identity that is faithful to the Tradition of the Prophet.This radio station strengthens forms of religious behavior and practice that in many respects fail to match the views of modern times.The Salafi-Wahhabi have a problem with modern issues, such as women's rights, technology, the national legal system and other things, and raise a variety of Islamic discourses on radio in a strict manner.They are inflexible in their preaching and tend to create intolerant, exclusive people.The issue is that the salafization of Indonesian Islam could pose a threat to the country through their 'brutal' criticism of the religious practices of Indonesian Muslims.
There might be a growing number of listeners to Rodja Radio, yet still only a few Indonesian Muslims adhere to the preaching of Salafism.I do not have an exact number of Salafi adherents, but this group is still (a very vocal) minority amidst of moderate Indonesian Islam.Even though the Salafi use the radio, which is a public sphere, to disseminate the message of 'Islamic Puritanism' in Indonesia, their dakwah is not very welcome among Indonesian Muslims in general.This is due to the rigidity and strictness of their dakwah.Moreover, Moderate Indonesian Islam, represented by NU (and Muhamadiyyah), as I explained above, has a strong network and basis in the Muslims' grassroots, which enables them to construct a counter-narrative to the Islamic discourse that is being disseminated by the Salafi-Wahhabi preachers via Rodja Radio.This is because, according to Robert Hefner, ‚Civil Islam‛ is prevailing in Indonesian Islam.This 'Civil Islam' is the Indonesian Islam version that ‚emerged in the 1980s and 1990s a democratic, religiously ecumenical, and boldly reformist movement that promote women's rights, inter-religious dialogue, and the struggle to create a democratic and pluralist polity.‛ 75The majority of Indonesian Muslims constantly promotes and strives to implement Moderate Islam and this 'Civil Islam' in Indonesia, despite the worrying rise of Islamic puritanism that may make Indonesian Islam more conservative.
45 ‚So whe n Our Commandment came, We turne d (the town of Sodom in Pale stine ) upside down, and raine d on the m stone s of bake d clay, pile d up‛.
Age (Lanham-London: Rowman & Little fie ld, 2017), 215-227.Se e the discussion on Wahhabi-Islam in its transformation from the re vivalist move me nt into a global te rror-maker as a consequence of the puritanical vie ws unde rstood by, for instance , Osame Be n Lade n, in an e xtre me ly important book: Natana J. De long -Bas, Wahhabi Islam: From Revival and Reform to Global Jihad (Oxford: Oxford Unive rsity Pre ss, 2004).
This is about a woman worke r.Afte r having gaine d knowle dge about the Sunnah (the Salafi inte rpre tation) and having liste ne d to this radio station she de cide s to quit from he r job and to de dicate he rse lf to he r husband.In the me antime, she wants to study for a BA de gre e and will ask he r husband for the tuition fe e s, what is the rule in Islam for such a woman? 57<+ First, the obligation of a wife is to se rve he r husband.Furthe rmore , the Prophe t, peace be upon him, said ‚If it we re allowe d to prostrate to a human be ing, I would ask the wife to prostrate be fore he r husband‛.The re fore , if you want to se ek the re ward and the ble ssing of Allah, you have to serve and obe y your husband.Se cond, wome n who work outside the ir home s will cause disorde r and chaos (fitnah), e ve n more so if the y only work to se e k worldly ple asure s or to purchase this and that, e tc.This is not allowe d be cause the ir ne e ds should be fulfille d by the ir husbands.It is not the wome n's task to work and to e arn mone y.Third, a wife who wants to study should obtain he r husband's consent and he r study must not intrude on he r obligations as a house wife .*<+ 55Rodja Radio broadcast on Friday, 12 Fe bruary 2016, from around 15.00 -15.45. 56Rodja Radio broadcast on Monday, 11 April 2016, around 17.47.* Ustadh, I have a daughter and she wants to work afte r he r graduation.What is the Islamic rule for a young girl to work? 59 A fathe r from an unide ntifie d place57Rodja Radio broadcast on Monday, 30 May 2016, around 14.53.58RodjaRadio broadcast on Tue sday, 10 May 2016, from around 18.30 -19.00.